Contents8 sections
After the BFH judgments, many owners and heirs in Baden-Wuerttemberg ask three things: Can their property tax value still be corrected? What deviation is required? And which notice do they have to challenge? This article classifies the decisions, explains how the land value model calculates and describes the correction routes. It is general information and does not replace advice in the individual case.
In a nutshell: In its judgments of 22 April 2026 (II R 26/24 and II R 27/24), the Federal Fiscal Court confirmed Baden-Wuerttemberg's State Property Tax Act. A different property tax value is only possible on application under § 38(4) LGrStG BW. A qualified expert report must prove that the actual value of the land at the main assessment date deviates by more than 30 per cent from the value under § 38(1) or (3) LGrStG BW. Errors in plot area or standard land value belong in the property tax value assessment, not in the base assessment.
What did the BFH decide on the land value model?
With two judgments of 22 April 2026 (II R 26/24 and II R 27/24), the II. Senate of the Federal Fiscal Court confirmed the State Property Tax Act of Baden-Wuerttemberg. From the headnotes to II R 26/24, three statements are particularly important for owners:
- The LGrStG BW is formally constitutional. The BFH bases this on the states' power to deviate under Art. 72(3) sentence 1 no. 7 of the Basic Law (GG).
- § 38 LGrStG BW is substantively constitutional. According to the BFH, it does not violate the principle of equal tax burden under Art. 3(1) GG that the state legislator ties the tax to the value of the land without distinguishing between built-on and undeveloped plots.
- Anyone wishing to prove a lower land value because of property-specific features can do so solely under the conditions of § 38(4) LGrStG BW.
This summary is based on the headnotes. The reasons for the judgments are not evaluated in detail here.
Context: the federal model and the interim decisions of 2024
The BFH ruled on the federal model on 12 November 2025 (II R 25/24 and II R 3/25). According to the first headnote, the Property Tax Reform Act of 26 November 2019 is formally constitutional. The BFH's interim decisions of May 2024 on the federal model concerned the legal situation at that time. Today, § 220(2) BewG expressly governs proof of a lower fair market value. The lower fair market value is to be applied if the taxpayer proves that the property tax value deviates substantially from the fair market value of the economic unit at the assessment date. This is to be assumed if the property tax value exceeds the proven fair market value by at least 40 per cent. A purchase price for the economic unit to be valued can also serve as proof if it was agreed in the ordinary course of business within one year before or after the main assessment date. The relevant circumstances must be unchanged compared with those at the main assessment date. This rule does not apply in Baden-Wuerttemberg, because the state deviates from the Valuation Act with the LGrStG BW.
Florian Enders discusses the topic BFH on Grundsteuer Baden-Wuerttemberg 2026 in the office
How does the land value model calculate in Baden-Wuerttemberg?
The land value model starts with the land. The calculation runs in three stages. Each stage has its own notice:
Property tax value = plot area × standard land value (property tax value assessment, tax office)
Tax base amount = property tax value × basic tax rate (property tax base assessment, tax office)
Property tax = tax base amount × municipal multiplier (property tax notice, municipality)
For plots, the basic tax rate is 1.30 per mille (§ 40(2) LGrStG BW). If the plot is used predominantly for residential purposes, the rate is reduced by 30 per cent (§ 40(3) LGrStG BW). This results in 0.91 per mille. The tax office notifies the municipality of the content of the base assessment, and the municipality then sets the property tax (§ 184(3) AO, Fiscal Code).
Federal model and land value model compared
| Criterion | Federal model | Land value model BW |
|---|---|---|
| Legal basis of the value | §§ 218 et seq. BewG | LGrStG BW |
| Basic tax rate | 0.31 per mille for built-on plots under § 249(1) nos. 1 to 4 BewG (§ 15(1) no. 2(a) GrStG) | 1.30 per mille, reduced by 30 per cent to 0.91 per mille for predominantly residential use (§ 40(2) and (3) LGrStG BW) |
| What has to be proven? | Substantial deviation of the property tax value from the fair market value of the economic unit at the assessment date (§ 220(2) BewG) | Actual value of the land at the main assessment date (§ 38(4) LGrStG BW) |
| When is the deviation sufficient? | Assumed if the property tax value exceeds the proven fair market value by at least 40 % | Only on application and with a deviation of more than 30 % from the value under § 38(1) or (3) LGrStG BW |
| Means of proof | Proof of the fair market value, also a purchase price for the economic unit to be valued within one year before or after the main assessment date with unchanged circumstances | Qualified expert report under § 38(4) sentence 2 LGrStG BW |
| BFH main proceedings | 12 November 2025 (II R 25/24, II R 3/25) | 22 April 2026 (II R 26/24, II R 27/24) |
The two basic tax rates cannot be compared directly, because they are applied to property tax values determined in different ways.
Property tax and inheritance tax are separate taxes. You will find a separate article on inheritance tax on real estate: Inheritance tax on real estate.
Which hopes are now over?
1. A general attack on the model
According to the headnotes, the Act is formally constitutional and § 38 LGrStG BW is substantively constitutional. Anyone basing an objection solely on the alleged unconstitutionality of the land value model finds no support in these judgments.
2. Blanket criticism of the standard land value
The fact that a standard land value seems too high is not enough. According to the BFH, a lower land value because of property-specific features can be proven solely via § 38(4) LGrStG BW. This requires an application, a qualified expert report and a deviation of more than 30 per cent between the actual value of the land at the main assessment date and the value under § 38(1) or (3) LGrStG BW. A simple error in plot area or standard land value in the notice is a different matter. For that case, the routes in the objection section apply.
Calculation example: what does a plot in Heidelberg cost?
The following example is fictitious. It is based on these assumptions: single-family home in Heidelberg, 600 m² plot, standard land value 1,800 euros per square metre, predominantly residential use, no application under § 38(4) LGrStG BW. The municipal multiplier is 185 per cent from 2025, as resolved by the municipal council on 12 December 2024. For 2026, please check the city's current multiplier statute (Hebesatzsatzung).
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Property tax value | 600 m² × 1,800 EUR/m² = 1,080,000 EUR |
| Basic tax rate, residential | 0.91 per mille (1.30 per mille, reduced by 30 %) |
| Tax base amount | 1,080,000 EUR × 0.91 ‰ = 982.80 EUR |
| Heidelberg multiplier (as resolved on 12 December 2024) | 185 % |
| Annual property tax | 982.80 EUR × 1.85 = 1,818.18 EUR |
The condition of the house does not enter into this calculation. A low sale price of the built-on property does not in itself justify an application under § 38(4) LGrStG BW, because what counts is the value of the land.
Are you taking over a property together with other heirs? Then also read the article Community of heirs with real estate.
What can owners and heirs do now?
Consider an application under § 38(4) LGrStG BW
- Requirement: A different value can be applied on application. For this, the actual value of the land at the time of the main assessment must deviate by more than 30 per cent from the value under § 38(1) or (3) LGrStG BW. Up to 30 per cent, that value stands.
- Yardstick: What counts is the land, not the sale value of the built-on property.
- Expert report: Proof requires a qualified expert report under § 38(4) sentence 2 LGrStG BW. This is a report by the competent valuation committee (Gutachterausschuss) or by persons appointed or certified as experts or valuers for the valuation of land by a state body, a state-recognised body or a body accredited under DIN EN ISO/IEC 17024.
- Existing assessment: If the value has already been assessed, § 16(1) and (4) sentence 3 no. 1 LGrStG BW apply accordingly under § 38(4) sentence 3 LGrStG BW. The value threshold of 15,000 euros does not apply in this case.
- Competent authority: The competent authority is the tax office for the property's location (Lagefinanzamt), i.e. the tax office in whose district the plot is located (§ 18(1) no. 1 AO, § 22(1) AO).
Objection against the property tax value assessment
The property tax value is assessed separately (§ 180(1) sentence 1 no. 1 AO, § 13 LGrStG BW). Plot area and standard land value enter into this value. The assessment notice is binding for the base assessment (§ 182(1) AO). Decisions in a basic notice (Grundlagenbescheid) can only be challenged by contesting that notice, not via a subsequent notice (§ 351(2) AO). The base assessment decides on the tax base amount and on personal and material tax liability (§ 184(1) AO). This includes the basic tax rate and the reduction for residential purposes. The Fiscal Code applies accordingly in Baden-Wuerttemberg via § 2(1) LGrStG BW.
How to proceed:
- Check the notice: Are the plot area and standard land value from which the property tax value is calculated correct? You challenge errors there in the property tax value assessment. Incorrectly recognised residential use concerns the base assessment.
- Meet the deadline: File the objection with the tax office for the property's location within one month of notification (§ 355(1) AO).
- After the deadline, route A: If the last assessment contains an error, an error-correcting update (fehlerbeseitigende Fortschreibung) under § 16(3) LGrStG BW may be considered. It is an update under § 16(1) or (2) LGrStG BW. A value update (Wertfortschreibung) under § 16(1) LGrStG BW requires the value to deviate by more than 15,000 euros. The 30 per cent threshold of § 38(4) does not apply to it. The update takes effect at the beginning of the calendar year in which the tax office becomes aware of the error. Where the property tax value is increased, it takes effect at the earliest at the beginning of the calendar year in which the assessment notice is issued (§ 16(4) sentence 3 no. 2 LGrStG BW).
- After the deadline, route B: If the actual value of the land at the main assessment date deviates by more than 30 per cent from the value under § 38(1) or (3) LGrStG BW, an application under § 38(4) LGrStG BW with a qualified expert report may be considered.
- Lawsuit: Recourse to the fiscal courts is available against decisions of the tax authorities (§ 2(2) LGrStG BW). As a rule, a lawsuit is only admissible if the objection has been wholly or partly unsuccessful (§ 44(1) FGO, Fiscal Court Code).
Important for heirs: A property tax value assessment also has effect against the legal successor to whom the plot passes with tax effect after the assessment date. If the succession occurs before the notice has been issued, it only has effect against the legal successor if it is notified to them (§ 182(2) AO).
Disclaiming the inheritance: assessing liability soberly
Running charges such as property tax can put an economic burden on an inheritance. In that case, disclaiming the inheritance may also be an option. The heir is liable for the estate liabilities (Nachlassverbindlichkeiten), which include the debts originating from the deceased (§ 1967 BGB, Civil Code). Liability is limited to the estate if estate administration (Nachlassverwaltung) has been ordered or estate insolvency proceedings have been opened (§ 1975 BGB). Independently of this, the property tax rests on the plot as a public charge (öffentliche Last) (§ 12 LGrStG BW). General information on disclaiming an inheritance can be found in the article Disclaiming an inheritance, and on the situation after the deadline has passed in the article Disclaiming an inheritance: deadline missed. On will planning between spouses, there is the article Berliner Testament.
Frequently asked questions
When did the BFH rule on property tax in Baden-Wuerttemberg?
The judgments II R 26/24 and II R 27/24 are dated 22 April 2026. According to the headnotes, the LGrStG BW is formally constitutional and § 38 LGrStG BW is substantively constitutional.
From what deviation is there a different property tax value?
Under § 38(4) LGrStG BW, the actual value of the land at the main assessment date must deviate by more than 30 per cent from the value under § 38(1) or (3) LGrStG BW. Proof requires a qualified expert report, and the different value is only applied on application. Up to 30 per cent, that value stands.
Which notice do I challenge if the plot area is wrong?
Plot area and standard land value enter into the property tax value, which is assessed in the property tax value assessment, and can only be challenged via that notice. The objection must be filed with the tax office for the property's location within one month of notification. Once the deadline has passed, an error-correcting update under § 16(3) LGrStG BW may be considered, which as a value update requires the value to deviate by more than 15,000 euros.
Can I still sue against my property tax notice?
Against notices of the tax office, a lawsuit before the fiscal court is as a rule only admissible if the objection has been wholly or partly unsuccessful. Valuation questions can only be resolved via the property tax value assessment, not via the base assessment or the municipality's property tax notice. How to proceed against the municipality's notice itself is not covered in this article.
Does the BFH ruling also apply to other federal states?
The judgments II R 26/24 and II R 27/24 concern the State Property Tax Act of Baden-Wuerttemberg. In the federal model, under § 220(2) BewG a substantial deviation is to be assumed if the property tax value exceeds the proven fair market value by at least 40 per cent. This provision does not apply in Baden-Wuerttemberg, because the state deviates with the LGrStG BW.
Are heirs liable for outstanding property tax?
The heir is liable for the estate liabilities, which include the debts originating from the deceased (§ 1967 BGB), limited to the estate in the case of estate administration or estate insolvency proceedings (§ 1975 BGB). Independently of this, the property tax rests on the plot as a public charge (§ 12 LGrStG BW). Whether a specific outstanding claim is one of the estate liabilities must be examined in the individual case.
Conclusion and next steps
The BFH has confirmed the land value model. Two separate routes remain: you correct errors in plot area or standard land value via the property tax value assessment or, if the value deviates by more than 15,000 euros, via an update under § 16(3) LGrStG BW. A different value because of a deviating actual land value requires, under § 38(4) LGrStG BW, an application, a qualified expert report and a deviation of more than 30 per cent between the actual value of the land at the main assessment date and the value under § 38(1) or (3).
Do you have an inherited property, or one you expect to inherit, in Baden-Wuerttemberg and are unsure whether the running charges will remain bearable? Then speak with me. In an initial consultation we clarify which questions need to be examined in your case, for example an application under § 38(4) LGrStG BW, inheritance tax or a disclaimer of the inheritance.
Book an initial consultation.
Sources and status
- Federal law: Fiscal Code (AO), Valuation Act (BewG), Civil Code (BGB), Fiscal Court Code (FGO) and Property Tax Act (GrStG), retrieved on 1 November 2026 from gesetze-im-internet.de (links in the text).
- State law: State Property Tax Act of Baden-Wuerttemberg, complete edition on landesrecht-bw.de (link in the text), last amended by the Act of 18 November 2025.
- Case law: BFH, judgments of 22 April 2026, II R 26/24 (ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:U.220426.IIR26.24.0) and II R 27/24. BFH, judgments of 12 November 2025, II R 25/24 and II R 3/25. In each case, the headnotes have been evaluated.
- Calculation example: fictitious, assumptions as stated in the section. Heidelberg multiplier as resolved by the municipal council on 12 December 2024.
This article reflects the general legal position and does not replace advice in the individual case.

Clarity in a personal conversation
Florian Enders will respond to you personally
You now have an overview. In a free initial consultation we assess your situation and show the concrete next steps.
Free guide
Succession Checklist
7 items to review today
Free practical guide for entrepreneurs and families with assets. Includes BGB and ErbStG (German Civil Code and Inheritance Tax Act) references, instant checks and practitioner notes.
- ✓ 10 pages, instant access
- ✓ 7 quick checks to tick off
- ✓ Instant PDF download